Key takeaways
- Define value from the patient's point of view, then map the steps to see which ones add it.
- Look for the eight wastes on your own unit. Waiting and motion are usually the easiest to see.
- Treat lean as a way of managing every day, with huddles, visual boards and leaders at the gemba, not a toolkit for occasional projects.
- Expect process gains first. Evidence on patient outcomes is thinner, so measure them directly.
What lean is
Lean is a management system that aims to deliver more value to patients by removing waste from the way work is done. It grew out of the Toyota Production System and was described for a general audience by James Womack and Daniel Jones in Lean Thinking (1996). Healthcare organizations such as Virginia Mason Medical Center and ThedaCare adopted it in the early 2000s, and IHI helped spread it.
Womack and Jones's five principles, in healthcare terms:
- Value: define it from the patient's point of view, not the organization's convenience.
- Value stream: map every step in the patient's journey and separate the steps that add value from those that don't.
- Flow: remove the delays, rework and handoffs that make patients wait.
- Pull: respond to actual patient demand rather than pushing work through on a fixed schedule.
- Perfection: keep improving, because there is always more waste to remove.
The eight wastes in healthcare terms
The Toyota Production System named seven kinds of waste. Many lean practitioners add an eighth, unused talent. Each has a familiar healthcare form:
- Defects: medication errors, missing information, rework and repeated tests.
- Overproduction: work done before it is needed or not needed at all, such as unnecessary tests.
- Waiting: patients waiting for beds, results and discharge; staff waiting for information and equipment.
- Unused talent: frontline staff who see the problems but aren't asked to help solve them.
- Transportation: moving patients, specimens and supplies further or more often than necessary.
- Inventory: excess supplies, expired stock, and backlogs of work or information.
- Motion: staff walking to find supplies, equipment or colleagues.
- Extra processing: duplicate documentation and steps that add nothing for the patient.
ImprovementFlow
Tiered Huddles
Lean depends on daily management. Tiered Huddles gives teams huddle boards they build themselves, where metrics, action items and escalations reach the leaders who can resolve them.
What lean has achieved, and what the evidence shows
Early adopters documented striking process results. IHI's 2005 white paper reported that Virginia Mason's first 175 rapid process improvement workshops cut inventory by 53%, lead time by 65% and floor space by 41%, and that the capacity it freed let the organization avoid planned capital spending, including $6 million for new surgery suites.
The research evidence is more modest. A 2016 systematic review in the International Journal for Quality in Health Care found that of 22 lean studies meeting its quality criteria, none used high-quality designs such as randomized or quasi-experimental studies, and few reported patient health outcomes. Lean reliably helps with process measures such as flow and waiting; if you want to know its effect on patient outcomes, measure them directly.
Sources
- Institute for Healthcare Improvement, Going Lean in Health Care, IHI Innovation Series white paper, 2005 (opens in a new tab)
- Moraros J, Lemstra M, Nwankwo C, "Lean interventions in healthcare: do they actually work? A systematic literature review," International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 2016 (opens in a new tab)
Lean is a way of managing, not a toolkit
The most durable lean programs build the capability to improve every day. Organizations that treat lean as a set of tools run by a central team, or by occasional consultants, tend to see early results and then a plateau. Lean asks leaders to change how they spend their time and make decisions.
In practice, that capability usually rests on a daily management system:
- Short daily huddles at a visual board where the unit reviews safety, its measures and open problems.
- A clear route to escalate what the unit can't fix, so problems reach the leader who can.
- Leaders who go to the gemba, where the work happens, on a regular schedule.
- Standard work for frontline tasks and for leaders' own routines.
- Structured problem solving, such as A3s and PDSA cycles, for problems that need more than a quick fix.
Starting lean on one unit this quarter
- 1Start a daily huddle at a visual board with three or four measures the unit cares about.
- 2Ask staff to name the waste that frustrates them most, and fix a few small problems quickly so people see that raising them works.
- 3Have the manager and a senior leader walk the unit on a set schedule to see the work and follow up on what staff raise.
- 4Choose one larger problem for an A3, and keep its progress visible at the huddle.
How ImprovementFlow supports lean daily management
- Tiered Huddles gives each team a digital huddle board it builds and configures itself, with metrics, action items and recognition.
- Any card on a board can be escalated to the next tier, so a problem the unit can't fix reaches the leaders who can, with its context attached.
- Improvement Projects runs A3s and PDSA cycles with their measures attached, and GoodCatch captures the near-misses and small problems lean teams use as improvement signals.
